Tuesday, 7 July 2026

Olivia Rodrigo "You Seem Pretty Sad For A Girl So In Love" (2026)

 

Going three for three, Rodrigo returns upon intrepid stride. With no shortage of inspirations, this latest chapter documents her life's adventures, mainly dating, relationships and there emotional ups and downs. Opening numbers lean on this infatuated motif through airy upbeat, light hearted Pop Rock romps. A touch to sappy for my appetite but tolerable given how fruitful her collaborations with Daniel Nigro are.

For my liking, Maggots For Brain is where this record finds its voice. In come spangled 80s guitar licks, a strong hint at where things are heading. Olivia explores her relationship vulnerabilities candidly with poetically self depreciating lyrics to romanticize moody longings. From here that broad Post-Punk umbrella, Dream Pop, Shoegaze, New Wave, Synthpop, influence this current craft of intelligent songwriting.

In particular, the guitars take on this chorus tinged broody aesthetic, playing warm soulful melodies and gentle chord strumming. A beautiful resonance is struck, soft melancholy lingers never intruding on an upbeat underbelly. Every downtrodden notion feels as if resolution is insight. Olivia's words and voice carry a soft catharsis through this exercise of musical exorcism. Her lyrics expressed relive the burden.

A fascinating stride of songs bloom as Purple's playful vocal inflection's conjure favorable impressions of Elizabeth Fraser. The magnetic The Cure swoons. Surely an intention nod to the act with Robert Smith appearing on What's Wrong With Me, a dreary minimalist number for rainy days. Between them, a beautiful vocal oriented song, showcasing Olivia's talents, her voice holds a limelight harmonizing with herself.

It sets up a beautiful stride to the records dramatic conclusion. Expectations proves relief, a fun, quirky number with punchy chiptune baseline. Its playful, cheeky, chirpy, a bright radio track similar to My Way earlier in the track listing. In fact, there's a handful of song styles here that are on rotation from front to back. Together, they signal obvious 80s influences and structure a cohesive fifty minute album experience.

This third installment, You Seem Pretty Sad For A Girl So In Love, gracefully moves forward feeling fresh, fun, and interesting. Although I've only spent a few weeks with it, it already feels like the soundtrack to my summer. Each returning spin a delight, despite being lukewarm on the first couple of tracks. Unlike Guts and Sour, it seems to lack that one killer track. A mild critique, given how much this one offers.

Rating: 8/10