As the Minecraft soundtrack series expands, its ability to have an impact on its own identity diminishes too. Three of our post-C418 musicians return for the lengthiest offering yet, delivering familiar tones and temperaments to their collective prior efforts. All new additions are welcome, yet only two tracks land with impact, meriting talking points. One fairly positive, the other dubiously negative. Both are record discs.
Aaron Cherof's contribution's are inline with the smooth sailing of Trails & Tails' breezy charisma. Once again we ride gentle currents, as lush instrumentation swells from lulls like subtle gusts of wind amassing from stillness. Featherfall's endearing bedtime warmth comes birthed from inconsequential melodies, gently rising into a nocturnal cradle-song illuminated by shimmering bells. Clearly the favorite of his for me.
Kumi Tanioka treads her line too, offering chilly, atmosphere minimalism through lonely piano pieces that unite with gentle murmuring synths. They carry an airy bass presence, enriching what little came before into an emotive ambiguity with a lack of boldness to latch onto. As such they pass by without keen distinction, fit for the games background but feeling quite inconsequential as melodies land without memorability.
Lena's bag is varied. Deeper throws back to the lurching menace of the Nether. Its distorted synth melody lurches between threatening percussive rattles and illusive melodies, rotating around its tense atmospheric swell. Eld Unkown swings from mystique to drama as its pacy baseline musters a sense of urgency. Endless dulls in its own aimless duration. A stiff, nostalgic dusty piano piece, plays into itself as meandering through the cobwebs of a sullen, empty, former home yield little. Its almost good but clearly lacking a sense of gratification from its own empty oddness.
The music disc Creator is a bop. Bolder and bruising with an ensemble of classic, non electronic instruments, Lena forges cheeky melodies with a splash of Rock and foreign piazzas that is hard to deny. Lively and jiving, its perhaps not "minecrafty" but the Music Box counterpart version shapes its main melody into that blocky frame.
Precipice is also a bop. Feels like Mojang were after two lively animated songs to amp up the variety in record discs. This one however felt too little overproduced, a heavy assemble of noisy instruments bordering on the electricity Ive heard in modern Progressive Metal bands like Plini and Sithu Aye. A wildly colorful and adventurous song but lacking the guile and identity to tie it back to Minecraft in a meaningful way.
With artists now making second and third contributions, the games vast music could be accused of becoming bloated. The soundtrack doesn't hone in on something new and distinct to offer the game like the Nether Update soundtrack did. Its an extension of prior compositions which has been enjoyable yet doesn't say much about the Tricky Trials and interestingly none of the music plays specifically for the Trials Chambers, perhaps a missed opportunity for some Minecraft battle music, all tho goes completely against the philosophy of its incidental, disassociated sound design to being with.
Rating: 6/10